INTRODUCTION – A DIFFERENT KIND OF STORY
Recently, someone came to the courthouse to inquire about “Gold Tooth Annie”. The County Recorder didn’t know about the story, but he contacted Marilyn’s sister, Zella Mae as he knew she was knowledgeable about local history. She couldn’t remember any details except she thought it happened in the late 1930’s or early 1940’s, so she called Marilyn. Marilyn remembered only part of the story – when she went with family members to Southwest City to shop or to see the Dr. or Dentist, when they crossed the Togie (Saratoga) Bridge someone would usually point to the top of the hill and say “That’s where Gold Tooth Annie lived. She was a poisoner.” That got a little girl’s attention.
Then Marilyn mentioned it to a group of women yesterday morning, and one said, “I think she died at a nursing home in Lanagan.” Armed with scant facts, Marilyn went to the library, where she knew that her sister, Zella, had collected articles about local crimes (among other topics) while she was the Librarian at the McDonald County library. Marilyn was told that they had looked for information as there had been some recent inquiries, but hadn’t found anything. Marilyn was free to look for herself if she wished….
Marilyn did wish. She sat down with books of old newspaper articles. Fortunately the articles were in chronological order. The first article she found was in the Pineville Democrat, July 11, 1940.
This will be a long post as Marilyn wanted me to transcribe the newspaper articles since most people don’t have ready access to the files of the McDonald County Library. Besides there are some parts of the story that you just can’t do justice to without a literal transcription. In other words, you just couldn’t make this stuff up.
First are photos of the three plotters: (L-R) Troy Markle, Mrs. Irene Ball, Charlie Markle. The transcriptions follow the photo below:

Pineville Democrat – July 11, 1940
Saratoga Woman Accused of Murder
Mrs. Irene Ball Charged with Poisoning Her Employer John Branson.
Prosecuting Attorney W.G. Tracy has announced that he will file a first degree murder charge against Mrs. Irene Ball, 48 years old, in connection with he alleged poison death of John Branson, 55, a widower, at Saratoga Springs, where they both lived.
Branson was found dead at this home at 7:30 Tuesday evening by C.A. Kirk, a neighbor, and Dr. R.E. Warmack, county physician, said he had been dead 15 to 18 hours.
Mrs. Ball implicated a neighbor of Branson, Troy Markel, 39, and charged that he mixed arsenate of lead with flour and that Branson used the mixture to make bread for his breakfast.
Mrs. Ball said she obtained the poison from the Branson home where she worked as housekeeper, and took it with the pan used in the Branson home for mixing batter to the Markel home nearby where Troy Markel mixed it with flour. She said both she and Markel went back to the Branson home and that she went in and put the pan where it was usually kept.
Markel and his father, Charley Markel are both under arrest. The younger man is expected to be held as an accessory in the alleged crime.
A coroner’s inquest will be held this morning in the Justice Court of C.C. Caldwell at Noel. Dr. Warmack and Dr. W.H. Horton removed Branson’s viscera which was sent to the State Highway Patrol chemical laboratory in Jefferson City to be examined. The physician stated that there were unmistakable signs of poisoning.
Some pieces of bread and the remainder of the batter have also been sent to Jefferson City for chemical analysis.
Poisoning of Branson was suspected when dead cats and chickens were seen about the house.
According to the story told by Mrs.
Ball, Branson and the Markels had been quarreling and that they had persuaded her to poison Branson.
The younger Markel maintains that he knows nothing of the poison and that he went with Mrs. Ball to the Branson home after she told him that chickens and a cat had died there.
Mrs. Ball said that Markel accompanied her to the Branson home Monday evening and found Branson suffering. He begged for a drink of water she said, but Markel would not allow her to give it to him.
Mrs. Ball said that she had recently left the Branson home because he refused to buy her clothes or allow her to seek outside employment.
[Editorial comments: Marilyn marked in bold a couple of statements that made her stop and re-read them. They wouldn’t be in today’s papers.
Dr. Warmack was our family doctor for many years. He was the only M.D. in the county when Marilyn was growing up. He last treated her when she was 2l years old in 1962. Dr. Horton was the physician who delivered both Zella and Billy Max at home births. Faithful readers know that Marilyn was born at Cardwell Hospital. It seems there was a lot going on during the summer of her birth.
They were pretty cold hearted to deny a dying man a drink of water.
I sounds like Mrs. Ball may have had additional duties in addition to housekeeping.]
Pineville Democrat – July 18, 1940
Three Held In Poison Murder Charge
Chemical Analysis Reveals Aged Man Died From Poisoning
A report from the chemical laboratories of the state highway commission at Jefferson City revealed that John Branson, 55–year old resident of the Saratoga community, came to his death Tuesday, July 9, as a result of arsenate of lead poisoning.
Two men and a woman, charged with first degree murder, are being held in connection with the death. The aged man was found dead on the floor of his home late Tuesday afternoon, July 9, by a neighbor, C.A. Kirk.
An investigation of the death by local officers and the state highway patrol led to the arrest.
Mrs. Irene Ball, 48, a former housekeeper at the Branson Home; Troy Markel, 27, a neighbor, and Markel’s father, Charles Markel.
Died of Poison, Jury Finds
Prosecuting Attorney W. G. Tracy filed the charges after an Elk River township coroner’s jury Thursday afternoon found Branson came to his death “by violent poison” mixed in food. The inquest was held before Justice Caldwell at Noel.
Meanwhile Tracy advanced the theory that the motive for Branson’s death was a purported desire to obtain control of the property where Branson resided.
Branson had been caretaker of the farm, which was owned by a Kansas man, and Tracy said he has a letter purportedly written by Mrs. Ball and the younger Markel to the Kansas owner asking if they might “take care of the place.” Tracy said the letter was written Monday, the day before the body was found.
Previously, Tracy had obtained a sworn statement from Mrs. Ball declaring that she obtained the poison at the request of Troy Markel, and that it was mixed with flour. Markel and his father deny any connection with the case.
The viscera from Branson’s body was sent to the state highway patrol laboratories in Jefferson City for tests to determine whether poison caused his death.
[Editorial comment: Troy became 20 years younger in this account. A typo? Note the ages of those involved seem very fluid depending on the reporter. It is interesting also that the victim was “aged” when one of the killers was older than he. and he was only 7 years older than Mrs. Ball]
The Pineville Herald – August 29, 1940
Mrs. Irene Ball Enters Plea of Guilty
Mrs. Irene Ball, 48 years old, one of the three persons charged with first degree murder in the poison death last July 9th of John Branson, 55, a farmer near Noel, pleaded guilty before Judge Emory E. Smith in circuit court here Monday. Judge Smith deferred passing sentence until the close of the August term of circuit court which began here Monday.
Troy Markle, 27, and his father Charles Markle, 57, both charged with Mrs. Ball, pleaded innocent when they were arraigned before Judge Smith Monday and their trial was set for Tuesday September 3.
The three were arrested last July 10, the day after Branson, a bachelor, was found dead at his home near Saratoga. Authorities stated an autopsy disclosed Branson died from poisoning, and a cororner’s jury found that he came to his death by poison administered by the two Markles and Mrs. Ball, a former housekeeper for Branson.
Mrs. Ball later made a sworn statement Prosecuting Attorney. W.G. Tracy said, admitting that she mixed poison in flour at the Branson home and received $5 from the younger Markle for obtaining the poison.
The three have been held here in the county jail since their arraignment last July 12.
The state contends the Markles instigated the alleged poison plot against Branson in order that they might gain control of the property on which he lived, and which is owned by a Kansas man.
The Pineville Herald – September 12, 1940
Noel Farmer Freed of Charge
A first degree murder charge against Charles Markel, 57, Noel farmer, shown above [no photo in the file], was dismissed here last week in circuit court upon recommendation of Prosecuting atty., W.G. Tracy, but his son, Troy Markel 27, held on a similar charge, remained in jail for trial at the February term of court.
The two were charged last July 12 with the poison murder of John Branson 55, of near Noel, Mrs. Irene Ball, 48, also charged with the two men, entered a plea of guilty at the opening of the August term of McDonald county circuit court 15 days ago.
Judge Smith announced he will pass formal sentence on Mrs. Ball at eh conclusion of the Markel case. Mrs. ball and Troy Marcel are both being held here in the McDonald county jail without bond.
The Pineville Herald – November 14, 1940
Father, Son Admit Parts In Poisoning
Charles Markle, 64 year old McDonald county farmer, and his son, Troy Markle, 38 Tuesday made confessions before assistant prosecuting attorney James Paul, the latter announced that they were implicated in the Poison (sic) death last July of John Branson, neighbor farmer.
Mrs. Irene Ball, who had been Branson’s housekeeper, had confessed her part in the crime shortly after her arrest July 10 and had implicated the two men. She is awaiting sentence on a first degree murder charge after having pleaded guilty in circuit court in August to the charge.
The senior Markle and his son also were charged in the original information with first degree murder. The younger Markle pleaded innocent when arraigned, and the charge was dropped against Chas. Markel.
Mrs. Bell (sic) and Troy Markle have been held in jail since. Charles Markle was rearrested two week (sic) ago and a new charge of first degree murder filed against him.
According to the signed confession, Mrs. Bell, who was housekeeper for Branson, tenant on a farm between Noel and Southwest City carried out the act of putting arsenic of lead in pancakes after the two had plotted it.
Young Markle, it was brought up, according to Paul, was jealous because of domestic troubles with Branson, while the elder Markle had quarreled with Branson over a strawberry plot and the sale of the berries.
The three are being held in the jail with out bail trial of the Markles is schedules (sic) at a special term of court about December 10.
Branson ate poisoned pancakes the statement said, July 5, but did not died until July 9.
Pineville Democrat – November 14, 1940
Two Confess Part in Poison Murder
Father and Son Admit Planning the Murder of John Branson Last July
Charley Markle, 64, and his son, Troy Markel, 35, Tuesday night admitted and signed statements that they planned and aided in the poison murder of John Branson of the Saratoga community last July 5. The statements were made to James Paul, assistant prosecuting attorney, who has been working on the case for several days.
According to the statements, Troy Markle gave Irene Ball, who had been Branson’s housekeeper, a note in Noel asking her to come to the Markle home, that there was something they wanted done and there might be some money in it.
Troy Markle was not at home when she came, but his father supervised the mixing of arsenic in pancake batter, which she took to the Branosn home.
Before going to the Branson home, at the suggestion of Markle, she cooked a part of the batter and ate a piece of the cake to make it appear that Branson had tried to poison her.
The poison batter and the partially eaten cake was taken to the Branson home on Friday July 5. On Monday, July 8, Irene Ball and Troy Markle went to the Branson home, according to their statements, to see if the old man was dead. He was not dead but very sick and asked for water. He was found dead several hours later by a neighbor.
The Markles gave as their reason for planning the murder that Branson had caused trouble between Troy and his wife and had quarreled with Charley over a strawberry patch.
The Markles were arrested immediately following the death of Branson, but the elder Markle was released during the August term of Court. He was re-arrested about two weeks ago. Both men are being held for circuit court.
Pineville Herald – Thursday, March 6, 1941
Three Get Penitentiary Sentences For Murder
Circuit Court Adjourned Saturday after Five-Day Session
Penitentiary sentences were pronounced in circuit court here Monday for Troy and Charley Markle and Mrs. Irene Ball after the Markles followed the example of Mrs. Ball in entering pleas of guilty for the murder of John Branson, aged man near Saratoga Springs last July.
The sentences pronounced were as follows: Troy Markle, 3 years; Charley Markle, father of Troy Markle, 25 years; and Mrs. Irene Ball, 25 years.
The guilty please of the two Markles came unexpectedly after preparations had been made for a jury trial Friday. Mrs. Ball entered her plea of guilty in the August term of court. the tree were placed under arrest about last July 9th after Branson had been found dead at his home where he lived alone. Death was attributed to poison after an autopsy was performed. the tree admitted putting lead arsenate into batter from which the aged man cooked and ate pancakes.
[Other cases discussed in next paragraph are omitted here; in the same article the following:]
Divorces Granted
Divorces were granted in the following cases: Eva Markle vs. Troy Markle; ….
Joplin Globe – December 10, 1969
Mrs. Irene Ball
ANDERSON, MO. – Mrs. Irene Ball, 77, died at noon Tuesday in a local nursing home where she had been a patient 12 years.
Mrs. Ball was born Sept 27, 1892 in Michigan.
There are no immediate survivors.
Arrangements will be announced by Ozark Funeral Homes.
Joplin Globe – December 12, 1969
Mrs. Irene Ball
ANDERSON, MO. – Services for Mrs. Irene Ball, 77, Anderson, who died at noon Tuesday at a local nursing home, will be at 10 a.m. Saturday at the Ozark Funeral Home Chapel. The Rev. Dean Royce will officiate. Burial will be in the Anderson Cemetery.
POSTSCRIPT
And that is the end of the story. No one seems to remember why Irene was called “Gold Tooth Annie.” One would presume she had a gold tooth & that either her nickname or middle name was Ann, but so far, no clues. If any of my readers know the answer, please let me know by posting a comment.
Lucky
Recent Comments